In a run of nine dates from the Carson City Mint’s half eagle production starting in 1870 and ending in 1878, all are considered scarce. The 1874-CC date stands out among these as the most “common.” This is because this date’s estimated surviving population hovers between 200 and 250 (in all grades).

In many other series of U.S. coins such a figure would qualify the date as extremely rare. However, Carson City gold coins require their own rarity rankings. Collectors learn this quickly.

Collectors seeking higher grade 1874-CC half eagles, starting at the AU-53 level, also learn quickly that specimens with such ratings are seldom offered. Any notion of “common” fades fast. This is especially true regarding eye appealing pieces.

The PCGS AU-55+, CAC-approved example offered here is the only one thus certified by PCGS. A handful of specimens exist in PCGS AU-58 slabs (including one with a + Sign). Several Mint State pieces in PCGS holders sit atop the condition census.

The AU-55+ coin exhibits attractiveness that arguably qualifies for an AU-58 rating. In fact, some might claim PCGS graded this piece ultra conservatively. Luster radiates from its surfaces. When tilted at the right angle, a degree of prooflikeness reflects off them. All raised devices except at the crown of Lady Liberty’s head display exceptionally sharp detail for the grade. Liberty’s eyebrow, nose, and two lower hair buns show some weakness.

The coin’s color exudes a warm golden-orange-yellow hue that is quite alluring. Tiny contact marks and several light wafer-thin scratches are scattered across the obverse. A couple small scratches are barely noticeable between star 4 and Liberty’s forehead. A diagonal scratch on the left reverse field paralleling the eagle’s wing is the only abrasion worth mentioning on this side. Both obverse and reverse display very light hairlines in their fields.

This exquisite better-date “CC” half eagle will splendidly complement any high-grade set.